What Happens if You Refuse a Settlement Offer?

What Happens if You Refuse a Settlement Offer?

When involved in a car accident due to another driver's carelessness, you may find yourself dealing with the at-fault driver's insurance company, navigating the complexities of the claims process. You never want to do this alone; always have representation by a personal injury lawyer.

After submitting all necessary information to the insurance company, there's typically a waiting period as the insurance adjuster reviews the claim and decides whether to extend a settlement offer. An insurance settlement offer is essentially the insurance company's way of proposing a payment to cover your injury-related expenses and financial losses.

Accepting an insurance settlement offer allows you to close your claim. This process involves signing a liability waiver, which protects the insurance company from any future legal action from you in case you later believe the settlement did not fully compensate for your losses.

But are you obligated to accept the first offer from an insurance company? The answer is no.

Rejecting an offer opens the door to further negotiations. It's an opportunity to present additional evidence or documentation that those involved may have overlooked or to argue for a higher settlement amount that more accurately reflects the extent of your losses and expenses. It's a step that signals you believe the offer does not adequately cover the damages sustained from the accident.

In such situations, consulting with experienced Myrtle Beach car accident lawyer is advised. An attorney can evaluate the adequacy of a settlement offer and advise on the best course of action—whether to reject the offer and negotiate for more or to accept it. An attorney can guide you in making informed decisions to secure a settlement that truly compensates for your accident-related losses.

What Are the Grounds for Declining an Insurance Settlement Offer

What Happens if You Refuse a Settlement Offer

Ideally, the at-fault driver's insurance company should compensate for your injuries and financial losses after an accident. Yet, it's important to remember that insurance companies operate to maximize profits, often offering the minimal amount possible to resolve claims quickly and economically.

This approach can lead to tactics that aim to reduce the perceived value of your claim, especially when you're dealing with accumulating medical bills and may be feeling the pinch financially. The temptation to accept a quick settlement can be strong, particularly when it promises some relief, even if it falls short of fully covering your needs.

There are compelling reasons to consider rejecting an insurance settlement offer, including:

  • The Offer Falls Short: If the proposed amount doesn't align with the severity of your injuries or the financial burdens you've encountered, it's a clear sign to renegotiate.
  • Incomplete Coverage: When the settlement doesn't account for all your current and anticipated expenses, accepting it can leave you in a precarious situation.
  • Future Medical Needs: If your injuries may require ongoing treatment, accepting an offer before understanding the full extent of these future costs can be financially risky.
  • Maximum Medical Improvement Not Reached: Accepting an offer before reaching the point of maximum medical improvement (MMI) can mean settling for less than what's needed to cover long-term recovery costs.
  • Uncertainty About Total Losses: Early in the recovery process, the complete impact of your accident on your finances and well-being may not be fully evident.
  • Disagreement Over Liability: If there's a discrepancy between your view of the accident and the insurance company's assessment, you can stand firm until there's a fair evaluation.
  • Future Income Loss Concerns: For those whose injuries impact their ability to work, either temporarily or permanently, the settlement should include compensation for future lost income.
  • Merits of the Claim: Believing in the strength of your case and the facts supporting a higher settlement can justify rejecting an initial offer.

Facing the decision to reject an insurance offer can indeed be intimidating, but it's a crucial step that can lead to a more equitable resolution. By taking the time to carefully assess the offer and consult with a legal professional, you empower yourself to make informed decisions that align with your best interests.

With an experienced personal injury attorney's support, negotiating for what you truly deserve becomes easier. An attorney's role is to handle these negotiations on your behalf, aiming to secure a settlement that reflects the full scope of your losses and injuries.

What Goes Into the Decision to Decline an Insurance Settlement Offer?

What Goes Into the Decision to Decline an Insurance Settlement Offer

After a motor vehicle accident, many people find themselves thrust into the unfamiliar world of insurance claims, where the primary goal of the at-fault driver's insurance company is to settle claims as efficiently and cost-effectively as possible. This profit-driven approach can result in settlement offers that do not fully address the victim's needs or the true extent of their losses.

Given the financial pressures of mounting medical bills and the immediate need for relief, the initial offer may seem tempting. Still, it may not be in your best interest to accept it without careful consideration.

Here are detailed insights into the reasons for potentially declining an insurance settlement offer:

  • Inadequate Offer: When the settlement amount fails to match the gravity of your injuries or your financial challenges, it strongly indicates that negotiation is necessary.
  • Lack of Comprehensive Coverage: A settlement that doesn't account for all your incurred and future expenses can lead to financial difficulties.
  • Anticipated Future Medical Expenses: If ongoing medical care is anticipated for your injuries, accepting a premature offer can leave you without sufficient funds to cover these future medical costs.
  • Not Yet at Maximum Medical Improvement: Settling before reaching MMI means you might not fully understand the long-term impact of your injuries, potentially underestimating your compensation needs.
  • Uncertainty Regarding Full Extent of Losses: An accident's full financial and emotional toll often unfolds over time, making early settlement risky if all factors are apparent.
  • Dispute Over Liability: Differences in interpreting accident liability can significantly affect settlement outcomes. 
  • Concerns Over Future Earnings: For those whose ability to work has been affected, the settlement must reflect compensation for future earnings loss.
  • Strength of Your Case: A strong belief in the validity and value of your claim can be a valid reason to reject an offer that does not reflect the harm suffered.

Declining an insurance settlement offer can be hard, but it is a step towards securing a just resolution that reflects the extent of your losses and suffering. Having the support of an experienced attorney can transform this challenging process into a more manageable journey.

A personal injury attorney will advocate on your behalf, leveraging their experience to negotiate a settlement that accurately compensates for your injuries and associated losses. Their guidance ensures they protect your rights actively and represent your interests throughout the negotiation process.

Steps to Take After Declining an Insurance Settlement Offer

Steps to Take After Declining an Insurance Settlement Offer

Deciding to reject an initial settlement offer from an insurance company is a significant step in seeking fair compensation for your injuries and losses. It's wise to approach this decision with a clear strategy and understanding of the actions required to move forward effectively.

Here are key steps to consider when you're in the position of declining a lowball offer:

Thoroughly Document Your Losses

Proper documentation is the cornerstone of a strong personal injury claim. Ensure you have comprehensive records of all accident-related expenses, including medical bills, receipts for medication, documentation of lost income due to time off work, vehicle repair bills, and any out-of-pocket costs incurred because of your injuries. These documents are tangible evidence of your financial losses and can justify your counteroffer.

Write a Detailed Written Counteroffer

Typically, rejecting an insurance offer involves more than saying "no." It usually requires submitting a formal written response. This counteroffer should state that you are declining the initial proposal and present a well-reasoned demand backed by evidence. A personal injury lawyer can guide you in including detailed documentation of your losses and providing a clear rationale for the amount you request in a demand letter.

Brace for Negotiation

Rejecting an offer is the beginning of a negotiation process. Preparing for this phase is important, as it involves communication with the insurance company to reach a settlement that adequately compensates for your losses.

Negotiating can be a difficult process, particularly if you are still recovering from your injuries and dealing with the stress and emotional toll of the accident. An attorney can take on the negotiation process on your behalf, advocating for your interests and striving to secure the compensation you deserve.

Having a personal injury lawyer by your side can significantly impact the outcome of your claim. Legal professionals bring negotiation experience, an understanding of personal injury law, and experience dealing with insurance companies' tactics. They can provide strategic advice, protect your rights throughout the negotiation process, and work tirelessly to achieve a favorable outcome.

By following these steps, you can confidently handle the post-rejection phase of your insurance claim. Documenting your losses, submitting a well-written counteroffer, preparing for negotiation, and enlisting the support of a qualified personal injury attorney are all actions that set the foundation for achieving a fair and just resolution to your claim.

FAQs About Declining an Insurance Settlement Offer

Question One: Can I reject an insurance settlement offer?

A: You can reject an insurance settlement offer if you believe it does not adequately cover your losses and expenses incurred from the accident. It's a common part of the negotiation process in personal injury claims.

Question Two: What should I do after rejecting a settlement offer?

A: After rejecting an offer, you should prepare a detailed counteroffer that outlines why the initial offer was insufficient and what you believe is a fair amount. This should rely on thorough documentation of your situation damages, including medical expenses, lost income, and other related costs.

Question Three: Do I need a personal injury lawyer to reject an insurance offer?

A: While you can technically reject an offer independently, having an experienced personal injury lawyer can significantly improve your chances of securing a fair settlement. A lawyer can help write your counteroffer, negotiate on your behalf, and actively protect your rights.

Question Four: How do I know if an insurance offer is too low?

A: An offer might be too low if it doesn't cover all your medical bills, lost income, and other accident-related expenses or doesn't compensate for non-economic damages like pain and suffering. Comparing the offer to your documented losses and consulting with a personal injury attorney can guide you in determining if the offer is fair.

Question Five: What happens if I reject an offer and we cannot reach a new agreement?

A: If you reject an offer and negotiations with the insurance company do not lead to a new, acceptable agreement, you may need to consider legal action by filing a lawsuit. Your attorney can advise you on the best action and represent you in court if necessary.

Question Six: Can rejecting an insurance offer affect my claim negatively?

A: Rejecting an offer should not negatively affect your claim if your counteroffer is reasonable and supported by evidence. It's a normal part of the negotiation process. However, it's important to manage this process carefully, ideally with the assistance of a personal injury attorney, to ensure the best possible outcome.

Question Seven: How long do I have to decide whether to accept or reject an insurance offer?

A: The timeframe to accept or reject an offer can vary depending on the insurance company's policies and the specific details of your case. It's important to review any deadlines provided by the insurer. However, it's also best not to rush your decision—make sure you fully understand the extent of your damages and consult with an attorney if needed.

Question Eight: Can I negotiate an insurance settlement offer on my own?

A: Yes, you can negotiate independently, but it's often not recommended, especially for significant injuries or complex claims. An experienced personal injury attorney can offer valuable guidance and negotiation skills that contribute to securing a more favorable settlement.

Contact a Personal Injury Lawyer

Jeff Morris, Myrtle Beach Car Accident Attorney
Jeff Morris, Car Accident Lawyer

If you've received an insurance settlement offer and are considering whether to accept, reject, or negotiate for better terms, remember that you don't have to face this challenging process alone. Reach out to a personal injury attorney to get the support you need to make informed decisions and secure the compensation you rightfully deserve.


What Our Clients Say

Thank you so much for your advice! I highly recommend him! Mr. Morris was extremely helpful with helping me understand the situation.
What seemed very confusing to me he actually broke everything down so I could understand what everything meant. Thank you so much for your advice! I highly recommend him!

Crissy Blumer

I would highly recommend Morris Law Accident Injury Lawyers firm for any legal needs. I chose Morris Law Accident Injury Lawyers to represent me after a serious MVA. Jeff and Spencer worked hard to provide the best service by addressing all of our needs and concerns within a timely, professional manner. They were so friendly and alleviated all of the stress of our medical bills and legal issues. A 5 star rating is well deserved and I would use them in the future if needed!

Savannah Crosby

I highly recommend Jeff Morris and his team. They took really good care of me after my car accident.

Ashley Wright

I would absolutely recommend Morris Law Accident Injury Lawyers. He and his staff took great care of me with my MVA case.

Kristen Danielle West

They are the best. Helped me with a car accident case and i came out on top. The way they showed how much they cared for me and not just about the $$$ was all i needed. JEFF MORRIS AND ASSOCIATES ROCK

Charrise Parker

When I tell you I had a great team, I mean I had a GREAT team!! Mr. Morris & Spencer did far better than I could have ever expected handling my MVA. The effort that was required from me was extremely minimal. I literally paid nothing upfront and they were worth every penny they collected from my settlements! If you’re in the area, check them out; at least meet with them and give them a chance to hear you out. They’re worth it!!

Marie Batey

I highly recommend Jeff Morris. Him and his team took really good care of me after my car accident. He was very informative of the process and answered all my questions. The whole team is great!

Ashley Killough

Schedule A Free Case Consultation

At Morris Law Accident Injury Lawyers, we have provided compassionate and aggressive counsel to personal injury victims in Horry County, Aiken County, and throughout South Carolina since 2016. We are available 24/7/365 days of the year. Reach out and get your case evaluated at no cost.